Montauk Manor: experience an elegant hotel in the heart of beautiful Montauk

frank July 460

Montauk, N.Y. is one of the most unique towns in New York State.  Located at the very tip of the south fork of Long Island, Montauk is a fantastic summer vacation spot, steeped in history, great beaches , scenery and surrounded by water.  It’s laid back atmosphere, beaches, surfing and fishing draws visitors each year to this area which is a bit more akin to New England than New York State.

Though there are many options for accommodations, we discovered one that is a quite different.  Montauk Manor is a grand condo/hotel situated on  Signal Hill overlooking Montauk.  Its  architecture  is of a fine English Manor and is in contrast to the rest of the design found here at the end of the island.


Built in 1927 the hotel was the grand vision of Carl Fisher who imagined a 5 star resort to rival no other in the country.  It would have the hotel, beach club, a boardwalk,  polo fields, and much more. The hotel and its restaurants would offer the finest of food and amenities. Though the hotel opened to much fanfare, the economic downturn of the Great Depression took its toll on Mr. Fisher’s ambitious plans.

Luckily, the Montauk Manor has survived the long decades and has been totally restored into a beautiful condo/hotel  and the fantastic views from the top of Signal Hill remain.

frank July 463

Beautify view from the hotel

Rooms at the hotel are suite style and available in Studio, and One to Three Bedroom units.  Many have water views.  The two bedroom unit we stayed in (party of 4), included a full kitchen, kitchen table, living area, master bedroom with en suite bath, and loft bedroom with bath.  The suite was modern, updated and tastefully decorated.  Our stay was very comfortable, and the room was quiet.

The hotel does have one restaurant on site, La Fine.   There is an indoor pool and spa, outdoor pool, tennis, putting green , golf driving course, bocce court and  indoor fitness center.   The views from the lawn are beautiful as you can watch the sun set over Long Island Sound.

frank July 476

The outdoor section of La FIne

The charming village of Montauk is two minutes by car and there are plenty of shops and dining options for the visitor.  The beach is just another short drive away depending on what beach you wish to visit.  The hotel also provides a shuttle to and from the beach for you.

If you are looking for an upscale resort experience with old world charm and elegance, then I encourage you to check out Montauk Manor in Montauk. We cannot wait to return!

frank July 416

Montauk Manor

236 Edgemere Street, Montauk, NY

tel 631.668.4400




Like I On the Valley on Facebook

instagram @ i_on_the_valley


One thought on “Montauk Manor: experience an elegant hotel in the heart of beautiful Montauk

  1. Pingback: Montauk: A two day tour of sun, sea, sights and eats. | I On The Valley

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s